Fat Talk! Plus size fashion promotes obesity? Whatever!

Hi! I’m Natalie and I am obese. I am fat. I am also female. Gemini. A Daughter, Sister, Auntie. I am human. I am pretty healthy. A lot healthier then a lot of people. I am human & I deserve fashion. I have the same right as any other woman, be it a size 4, 12, 32, to have clothes that are made well and are fashionable.

Gorgeous plus size ladies at the Gisela Ramirez Encore performance.

The Australian‘s fashion editor, Damian Woolnough wrote on Wedneday

The models were gorgeous, the clothes were unremarkable and the message about health was dangerous. Professional models, including plus-size pin-up Robyn Lawley, strutted and pouted alongside 10 winners of a competition run by Myer and The Australian Women’s Weekly. Most of the models looked healthy but some looked obese. While most fashion festivals ban models for being too skinny, why is it OK to see fat women on the runway? {Full article HERE}

Now, I know in my head, I often think to myself the whole BMI, obesity weight range is a bunch of bullshit. I also know, when I look at a woman, I don’t tend to look at them as a size. Honestly, with apperance, I take in how a person is clothed. I don’t think ‘holy shit, she’s fat’ or ‘wow, she’s so bloody skinny’. My brain doesn’t work like that. If i’m walking down the street and ‘judging a book by it’s cover’, my head is going through ‘well, I like her top, but I wouldn’t pair have worn that skirt with it’. Though I never let how someone looks, be it size, gender, ethnicity or clothing style, distract me from learning who the person behind all of that is.

Models from the Myer BiB show. Photos by Katie Parks.

The models used for Tuesdays Big is Beautiful show was a mixture of professional plus size models and a range of everyday ladies who won a competition to walk the catwalk. Everyday Australian woman! I believe the largest was a size 22. Sure, ‘officially’ that could mean one or two of those ladies are classified as ‘obese’, but so what? I’m sure there are a fair few models out there that would be classified as ‘underweight’ but there is in no way as much hoo-ha out there about THAT promoting negative imaging!

I also know a lot of people talk about the size of ‘plus size models’. Em wrote a great post titled ‘Pin her or Pad her‘. Most clothing companies use models who are in the smallest side range of plus size, adding to that, to be any kind of model, first off you must be 5’8 or taller. So what is considered plus size in the modelling world, a size 14, is not generally the body image of an everyday woman within the same weight range.

Images from Vogue. Elle & Robyn’s Facebook.

Take Robyn Lawley for example. A gorgeous Australian Plus Size Model (She was born in a suburb around 10 minutes from where I live!). In fact, she is the first plus size model to be used in Vogue Australia. Her stats, Size 12. 6ft. 36D-32-42. That is a plus size in the modeling world. No doubt, she is gorgeous, and larger then most models, but her body, well, it looks nothing like mine.

Clothing differences between sizes.

Retailers will never win with the on going debate of ‘what size models to use in campaigns’. Apparently smaller models show off the clothes better, they help ‘sell’ the product. While a lot of plus size woman want size 22-28 sized models, to show off what the clothes look like on their figures. I have to say, clothing can look so much different from size to size. I personally love seeing a larger lady in advertising, I can look at it and think ‘Wow! That is what I would look like!’. That being said, a company can’t shoot a catalogue featuring all sizes, or all shapes. Personally, that is why I LOVE blogs. I’ve gone and bought multiple dresses online after seeing a blogger wear it, when originally I didn’t like the look at all of the image on the site.

Larger ladies modelling clothes! Tess rocks a Domino Dollhouse dress & Gisela dons her own designs.

NO! Using plus size models on the catwalk isn’t promoting obesity.
YES! Plus size women can be healthy! We can be happy, sexy and fashionable too!

We come in all shapes and sizes, and we are all beautiful in our own way. No one has the right to tell us otherwise!

Share
  • http://twitter.com/FatAus Bronny

    Great post girl, that article in the Australian was seriously ridiculous.

  • Bethany Rutter

    I know it’s not ‘the point’ of this article, but I’m glad in the original quote he called the clothes ‘unremarkable’. What we need is less clothes like *that* and more clothes like what Gisela Ramirez does because those are remarkable and the kind of clothes fat chicks deserve. 

  • http://extralargeaslife.com/ Natalie Mulford

    Oh I couldn’t agree more! I even said in my post about the show, that basically, it was underwhelming & very safe. I want more form fitting, more boundary pushing plus size clothes.

  • http://www.nessbow.webs.com Nessbow

    You’re very right.  Plus Size clothing doesn’t promote obesity.  Making gorgeous, fashionable clothing in all sizes reinforces the message that everyone is beautiful, no matter what their size.  Everyone deserves the opportunity to wear something that they truly love, that makes them feel like the most fantastic version of themselves.  If stores suddenly stopped stocking plus size clothing, it wouldn’t encourage obese women to lose weight, it would just make them feel more ashamed about their appearance. 

  • kathryn

    So much agreed.  I want to see what the clothes look like on a plus size body, not pinned back on a thin one.  If clothes have been pinned, you have no idea how they look worn or how they hang.  It’s not promoting obesity, it’s being real. 

    His point is totally invalid.  Plus size models show the clothes the way the customers wear them.  They reflect the body of the customer.  Regular size models that get the flak are usually much thinner than the average customer can realistically be (and often on drugs or doing other life threatening behaviour to maintain that weight).  No one is going to stack on weight to emulate their favourite plus size model but young girls do endanger their lives to get the look of “regular” size models.

  • http://fatheffalump.wordpress.com/ Fat Heffalump

    Ugh, I get so sick of the whole “promoting obesity” bullshit.  As if anything could promote obesity when the entire societal message towards fat people is that they shouldn’t exist.  BAH!

  • Dazzlar1974

    I would like flattering too!!  I don’t want to look like a neon freak, not saying that these designs do but a bit of style is essential!

    Most of the collections at Myer’s were very dull in colour!

    Michelle 

  • http://katieparks.com Katie

    Thank you so much for using my images in your post!

    x

    Katie Parks

  • Paige

    While I admire most of what you are saying here and also disagree that catwalk models should be the size of toothpicks, I also disagree with quite how far you are taking this obesity talk. Yes, catwalks should include plus size models and yes clothes should be made and shown to flatter bigger sizes but size 22? Thats not healthy either. Putting a size 22 on the catwalk will become just as bad as placing anorexic models on a catwalk. If you argue that girls shouldn’t be anorexic, then I argue that girls also should’t be obese. And yes, I’m going to openly admit that I’m a size 8, not anorexic but smaller than many. I don’t go around parading my size, I become frustrated when people judge me for it and believe I wont understand simply because I am not bigger but if we are all to accept people for their size then shouldnt this also mean that you accept all those anorexic? And could you really support someone who believed that their optimal size was that of skin and bones, enough to make them riddled with health problems? I don’t think so, its the same with those that are obese. It isnt healthy.

  • http://www.facebook.com/people/Fred-Flinstone/1302760227 Fred Flinstone

    This is absolutely ludicrous!!!! Robyn Lawley is FAR from fat or overweight. She is NOT a plus size model in what today’s terms are. AND she’s not anorexic either like all the mainstream models. She is just right. But for these fat women to try and JUSTIFY their morbid obesity as something to be proud of, or accepting of is absolutely insane. Hey, to each their own. If that makes them happy, then so be it. But when they are 50, they will be paying the price as their health deteriorates. People who are fat don’t eat right. Period. And if fat people want to challenge that, I challenge YOU to keep a food diary and then go to a health care provider who IS in shape, like Robyn Lawley, who understands nutrition, and see what they say about your food diary.

  • Josh

    These fat women look gorgeous.

  • http://www.facebook.com/caitlin.swartz Caitlin Rafiki Swartz

    I am all for loving your body

Compression Plugin made by Web Hosting